What this calculator does
It compares buying a real Christmas tree every year with buying an artificial tree once and using it for several seasons. You type the prices. The table shows the running total for each year, and the result shows which choice costs less over the years you chose and the first year the artificial tree costs less in total.
How the numbers work
- Real trees, total after year y = stand + y × (tree price + yearly costs such as delivery or disposal).
- Artificial tree, total after year y = trees bought × price + storage bag or box + y × yearly costs. A new artificial tree is bought when the old one reaches the number of years you entered.
- Lights and ornaments are left out: they cost the same either way.
An example
With the example numbers (an $80 real tree plus $10 a year and a $30 stand; a $250 artificial tree, a $25 storage bag and $5 a year, replaced after 8 years), the artificial tree costs less from year 3. Over 10 years the real trees total $930 and the artificial tree $575, including a second artificial tree in year 9.
Tips
- Many cities and counties collect or recycle real trees after the holidays: check your local government's website before paying for disposal.
- Count the space: if storing a large box is hard, add a yearly storage cost.
- Artificial trees are often cheaper after the holidays: type the price you would really pay.
- Put the tree in your holiday budget under decorations, and see what the lights cost to run with the holiday lights calculator.
Frequently asked questions
Is an artificial tree always cheaper?
No. It depends on the prices you pay and how many years you keep it. If you would replace it after a few seasons, real trees can cost less.
Does the calculator compare the environmental impact?
No. It compares money only, using the prices you type.
Why is inflation not included?
To keep the comparison simple. If you expect real tree prices to rise, type a higher yearly price.
Is my information saved?
No. The numbers stay in your browser and are not sent to us.